As a student, coming across a rubric that says you must use primary and secondary sources can sound more like another language than instructions. You may have a stack of research articles to use for an essay, but no idea how to tell which ones are primary and which ones are secondary; how do you know what counts? Even experienced essay writers second-guess themselves when it comes to this, and getting it wrong can cost points and weaken your argument. Therefore, understanding what each is and how to tell the difference will be the most important first step to writing any research essay.
Primary vs Secondary Sources: The Short Answer
In short, a primary source is firsthand evidence; original material by someone who took part in it directly, not someone reacting to it or writing about it at a later date. A secondary source is created later by someone who studied the primary source to interpret it, further analyze it, or utilize it to conduct more research on the same topic. Here's how it breaks down:
| Primary source | Secondary source | |
| What it is | Original, firsthand evidence | A later interpretation or analysis of the firsthand evidence |
| Created | During the event by a direct participant | After the fact |
| Author | A witness or contributor to the event | A scholar or journalist who wasn't part of the original evidence |
| Gives you | Original, raw material | Context and explanation |
| Typical examples | Letters, photos, original studies, speeches | History books, review articles, documentaries |
| Use it to | Support your own claims with evidence | Understand what other scholars think or contribute to a conversation |
If you are looking at the thing, it is primary; if you are looking at someone looking at the thing, it is secondary.
What Is a Primary Source?
A primary source is your direct access to an original event, study, or dataset. It doesn't necessarily have to be old. For example, an Amendment published in 2025 is a primary source, or even an interview you conducted last week. Similarly, the primary source doesn't even have to be true or unbiased. The only rule of primary sources is that they must be an original account, so a diary entry or a speech are also primary resources. What makes a source primary is simply that it's an original piece of evidence from a direct witness of the thing you're researching, depending on your field:
History: letters, diaries, speeches, census records, or newspaper reports
Example: The Gettysburg Address
Science: an original experiment, lab notes, raw data, clinical trials, or field observations
Example: Louis Pasteur's experiment that disproved spontaneous generation
Literature: Novels, poems, paintings or plays
Example: Shakespeare's King Lear
Social Science: surveys, interview transcripts, or government statistics
Example: The 2021 Labor Statistics Report
Law and Policy: The Constitution, statutes, court opinions, or executive orders
Example: The 17th Amendment
Journalism and Media: raw footage, press releases, or social media posts
Example: A video of the tsunami in the Philippines
The most important thing to keep in mind is that primary sources are original data that were created at the time.
What Is a Secondary Source?
A secondary resource includes anything an author gathers to explain, compare, evaluate, or argue. It's someone else's reaction to a primary source, rather than the original information. Some examples of secondary resources are:
History: A history book
Science: A literature review of longitudinal and cross-sectional experiments
Literature: A poetry analysis
Social Science: A research article that synthesizes previous research
Law and Policy: A law review or political commentary
Journalism and Media: News analysis written after an event
A secondary source is not better or worse than a primary source, but it accomplishes a different task by explaining context that a primary source doesn't provide, synthesizes multiple primary resources, or argues about what other experts have ascertained. Both primary and secondary resources are necessary to construct a solid essay.
Where Tertiary Sources Fit
Tertiary sources differ from both primary and secondary sources. Instead of providing some kind of evidence or argument, they simply condense the evidence, giving an overview of it for reference. Examples of tertiary resources are: encyclopedias, almanacs, library guides, and database indexes. In academics, tertiary sources are useful when starting out to orient yourself toward the topic at hand. They may help you better define the contextual vocabulary and find leads in the research. However, these are not meant to be integral parts of your essay, and they don't even need to be cited in your bibliography. They are meant to be used as a starting point, not a source of information that makes it into your essay.
The Same Source Can Be Both
Based on these definitions, the difference between primary and secondary sources seems pretty simple, right? So why do students get so confused about whether sources are primary or secondary research? The reality is that one source can be either primary or secondary depending on how you plan to use it in your paper. For example, a biography of Sigmund Freud is a secondary source if you're using it to describe Sigmund Freud's life and accomplishments. However, it can also be a primary source if you're using it to describe others' perceptions of Sigmund Freud's life and accomplishments. Similarly, a newspaper article about the presidential election can be a primary source if the writer was there. However, if they weren't, and they're simply writing about the event after the fact, it's a secondary source. The main point is that it all depends, even if it's the exact same resource. But there are ways to discern a solid answer.
A Four-Question Test for Any Source
1. Who made it?
Ask yourself whether the creator of the resource was a participant, a witness or an original researcher. If they are, then your source is primary. If the creator is someone studying the event or concept from the outside, or after the fact, the source is secondary.
2. When was it made?
If the source was during or close to the event in question, it is likely primary. If it was written way after, it's secondary. The main question is whether the author lived through it and can act as a firsthand witness to it.
3. What is it doing?
Ask yourself what the function of the resource is. If it's presenting original material, like data or creative work, it's primary. If it's explaining, summarizing, or arguing using other material as reference, it's secondary. A quick trick to find out is to look for an abundance of citations or phrases like "scholars argue." Those are references to outside resources.
4. What are you asking of it?
This is likely the most important question you will ask when deciding if a source is primary or secondary. This is because, as stated, the same source can be either primary or secondary, depending on your research question and what you are using the resource for. Therefore, it is important to question the audience that you are utilizing to get your point across in the paper, and whether that audience is a firsthand account or a later evaluation.
This test is important for all writers and is especially useful when you're learning how to write an annotated bibliography, since instructors prefer bibliography entries to state what kind of source each is and how you plan to use it in your research paper.
The Hard Cases, Settled
A journal article: Answering whether a journal article is a primary or secondary source depends on what kind of article it is. An article reporting on a new study with its own methods and results section would be primary, as researchers are presenting their own experiment. However, a review article or meta-analysis that summarizes other studies would be a secondary source, as it is referring to previously completed research experiments. They are utilized the same way when you learn how to cite a research paper, but they function differently in an argument depending on whether they are primary or secondary.
- Verdict: Check for a methods and results section. If it has one, it's primary, and if it doesn't, it's secondary.
A textbook: A textbook typically takes other research and uses it to teach concepts. Some instructors would classify this as tertiary sourcing, while others would say it's secondary.
- Verdict: When you use a textbook to learn about a topic, it's a tertiary/secondary source, but if your essay is about how textbooks portray historical events, the textbook becomes primary evidence.
An encyclopedia entry: Encyclopedia entries are compressed summaries without original evidence or arguments.
- Verdict: Tertiary.
A newspaper: A newspaper article is typically a report that's written at the time of an event, especially with eyewitness statements. However, some newspaper articles could be an analysis or op-ed piece that looks back at a previous event.
- Verdict: If the article's reporting on a current event, it's primary. If it's analyzing a previous event, it's secondary.
A website: Websites are difficult to categorize because they are a format of presenting information rather than a type of information. Government data pages, organizational websites, and digital archives could all be websites.
- Verdict: Review the content on the web page. Is it a firsthand account? An analysis of something previous? Or simply an index of information?
An interview you conducted: This is firsthand evidence that you created.
- Verdict: This is the purest form of primary sourcing.
A documentary: Documentaries are usually the filmmaker's interpretation of events that have already occurred, but could also include archival footage and eyewitness interviews that are primary material.
- Verdict: When you use a documentary to learn about its subject, it's secondary, because it's the filmmaker's interpretation of events. But if you're analyzing how the documentary represents its subject, or archival footage, the documentary itself is your primary source.
A dissertation: A dissertation typically reports on an author's original research, but depending on the field, it could also be a literature review or analysis.
- Verdict: Primary if it's new findings, secondary if it analyzes.
A translation of a primary source: As a general rule, a translated letter or piece of primary evidence still counts as primary. However, it's important to be aware that a translator's word choices can change the meaning.
- Verdict: Primary for the most part, but be careful of word choice.
How to Find Primary Sources
While it may seem difficult to find primary sources, many are publicly available and free to use. Here are some common ways to locate primary sources.
- Review the bibliographies of secondary sources.
- Utilize National Archives and libraries.
- Look for governmental data.
- Utilize your college's library database.
- Ask a librarian.
If you aren't able to find primary sources, remember that you can create them. Run your own survey or conduct your own interviews if your instructor approves it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are 10 examples of secondary sources?
Bibliographies, biographies, literary criticisms, review articles, literature reviews, documentaries, op-eds, book reviews, political commentaries, or law reviews.
Is a website a primary or secondary source?
A website can be primary or secondary depending on the content. Government data and blogs both exist on websites. It's important to review the content and use common tests to determine if a website's content is primary or secondary.
What is the difference between primary and secondary research?
Primary research is current and raw data collected at the time of an event or observation. Secondary data analyzes previous research of events that have already occurred.
You Be The Judge
If you read this entire article, you now have a basic rule and four main questions you can ask to discern if a source is primary or secondary every time. If the source is the evidence, it's primary; if it discusses the evidence, it's secondary. Even if a source seems primary, remember that it can always become secondary depending on what you are using it for. Therefore, you be the judge and consider how you are using it in your own writing to get your point across. Getting this correct makes your argument stronger and shows your instructor that you understand how to research properly.